World Building 101: What’s This Good vs. Evil Stuff?
Sunday, April 15th, 2007This is the most fun part (short of the actual writing) of the whole development of a book… determining whether a character will be good or evil, based on their morals vs. the morals of their people. I don’t determine whether a character is a hero or a villain for a reason, here… As far as I’m concerned, whether a character is hero or villain depends on their actions in correspondence to each other. But I firmly believe a hero can be (or at least do) evil, and a villain can be (or at least do) good. That’s determined by social mores.
Now, this particular area isn’t quite as much fun in contemporary fiction, because we’re all aware of what we consider to be morally repugnant. But what about the future, or another world, or even another dimension? They won’t necessarily have the same moral structure as we do today (after all, even just a hundred years ago, the idea of living together without being married was socially unacceptable in most Western society, but we don’t bat an eye at it today).
So, let’s take our sample series, and determine the morals of our society vs. the morals of our heroes and villains… *GRIN* This should be fun for all of you…
Martian society: Murder is a crime. However, murder of a Psi whose powers pose a threat to the safety and welfare of a normal human is not punished as strictly as the murder of a normal human.
Jack Peterson & Kathrin Cross (from ILLEGAL PURSUIT): Murder is murder. Jack’s a former Homicide detective, who sees no distinction in the violent loss of life, between Psi and non-Psi. Kathrin’s on a personal crusade to see the man who murdered her sister (a powerful Psi) locked up forever. Both are Psi, so naturally, this would colour their outlook on the law.
Josef Travinski (also ILLEGAL PURSUIT): He knows murder is a crime, but he believes Psis are dangerous animals which need to be exterminated for the safety of human society. While he is, in fact, the villain of this story, his views would not necessarily be considered wrong or morally repugnant by Martian society (even though WE recoil in horror at the idea). Ergo, by the morals of his time and location, he isn’t necessarily “evil.”
By the same token, to use another book’s characters as examples (still in the same series) as well, apply the same Martian society rule to this character, and try to see if you can guess if he’s considered good, or evil (not hero or villain, though)…
Xander Mylonas: He has dangerous Psi abilities to possess and drain the life energy from any lifeform, which he must do to sustain his own life, thanks to the radioactive parasites in his blood. He has confined himself to killing only criminals or those whose death is imminent for medical reasons. However, many of these people are non-Psi. By Martian standards, is he good, or evil?
As you can see, the determination of good and evil plays a very big part in character development (at least, for me) because it helps to tell me if this character is going to be honoured or hunted by his/her society, if he/she is going to get in trouble with whatever law (if, indeed, one exists… I have a series with a planet in it where no law exists, and you should see some of THOSE characters!) governs the land, and if he/she will ultimately end up justly rewarded (or punished) for his/her actions. This sets the first big action that will move us into the actual plot of an individual story…
Next, we get out of the realm of general world building, and into the arena of putting it all together, to craft the plot… Stay tuned!